Email this article 
Post a Comment From ‘Nations’ to ‘Archontias’ (I) ‘Sclavinia’ and ‘Sclavoarchontia’: Terms and Chronology
Abstract
This article deals with the terms ‘Sclavinia’ and ‘Sclavoarchontia’, which are used in historiography in different and even contradictory ways, and aims to clarify a highly complicated topic, investigating the ways these terms were used by contemporaries, trying to define differences between them and connecting their use with the political changes of the time. Topics discussed include the chronology of the terms’ usage, different ways in which they were being used, relations of ‘Sclavinia’ and ‘Sclavoarchontia’ with the Empire, their appearance and disappearance and the political processes connected with it, as well as the analysis of the existing interpretations. The first part mostly discusses chronology and some existing hypotheses. The second (and the main) part analyses the way these terms were used and tries to define them.
The hypothesis presented connects these terms with the re-establishing of imperial authority in the Balkans, marked in the sources by replacing the term ‘Slavic nations’, which had been used until the late 8 century to denote the independent Balkan Slavic societies and their lands. The Empire lacked the capacity for direct subjugation of the independent Slavic communities and was forced to rely on complicated measures including colonization and ensuring Slav cooperation in the process. In the themes where the Empire had enough power, Slavic communities were organized as ‘Sclavoarchontias’, who received archons from the strategos, paid collective tribute and served as symahoi, but kept some inner autonomy. The Empire also tended to ensure the cooperation of Slavic communities around themes by granting titles and subsidies to some powerful Slavic leaders, which led to the creation of client states known as ‘Sclavinias’. They were not part of the thematic system, they had their native and hereditary leaders recognized and affirmed by the emperor by titles and seals and act as imperial allies. A prototype of both had appeared at the end of the 7th c., but only when relations of such types had multiplied after Stauracius’ expedition in 783, corresponding generic terms appeared and became regular.
DOI: 10.31168/2305-6754.2020.9.1.1
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Acievski K., Makedonija vo sredniot vek, Makedonska enciklopedija, 2, Skopje, 2009, 822.
Angelov B., Kuev K., Kodov Hr., eds., Clement of Ohrid, Sabrani sachineniya, 3: Prostranni zhitiya na Kiril i Metodii, Sofia, 1973.
Antoljak St., Našite Sklavinii, Srednovekovna Makedonija, 1, Skopje, 1985, 121–126.
Barford P. M., The early Slavs, New York, 2001.
Bozhilov I., Knezhenie Slovensko or Sklavoarhontia, Medieval Bulgarian Literature, 28–29, 1994, 23–28.
Browning R., Notes on the “Scriptor Incertus de Leone Armenio”, Byzantion, 35/2, 1965, 389–411.
Brubaker L., Haldon J. F., Byzantium in the Iconoclast Era, c. 680-850. The Sources, Ashgate, 2000.
Bulić D., The Fortifications of the Late Antiquity and the Early Byzantine Period on the Later Territory of the South-Slavic Principalities, and their Re-occupation, S. Rudić, ed., The World of the Slavs, Studies on the East, West and South Slavs: Civitas, Oppidas, Villas and Archeological Evidence (7th to 11th Centuries AD), Belgrade, 2013, 137–234.
Charanis P., Observations on the History of Greece During the Early Middle Ages, Balkan Studies, 11/1, Thessaloniki, 1970, 1–34.
Chrysos Ev., Settlements of Slavs and Byzantine sovereignty in the Balkans, K. Belke, E. Kislinger, A. Külzer, M. Stassinopoulou, eds., Byzantina Mediterranea. Festschrift für Johannes Koder zum 65. Geburtstag, Vienna, 2007, 123–135.
Constantine Porphyrogenitus, De Administrando Imperio (Dumbarton Oaks Texts, 1), G. Moravcsik, ed., R. J. H. Jenkins, trans., Washington, 1967.
Conterno M., Theophilos, “the more likely candidate”? Towards a reappraisal of the question of Theophanes’ “oriental source(s)”, M. Jankowiak, F. Montinaro, eds, Studies in Theophanes (= Travaux et Mémoires, 19), Paris, 2015, 383–400.
Curta F., Eastern Europe in the Middle Ages (500–1300) (= Brill’s Companions to European History, 19), Leiden, Boston, 2019.
Curta F., Sklavinia in Theophylact Simocatta, (hopefully) for the last time, Porphyra, 15 (27), 2018, 4–15.
Curta F., Sklaviniai and Ethnic Adjectives: A Clarification, Byzantion Nea Hellás, 30, 2011, 85–98.
Curta F., Southeast European "Dark Ages” (c. 600-c. 800), Cambridge, 2006.
Curta F., The Edinburg History of the Greeks, c. 500 to 1050: The Early Middle Ages, Edinburg, 2011.
Curta F., Theophylact Simocatta revisited. A response to Andreas Gkoutzioukostas, Byzantion Nea Hellás, 35, 2016, 195–209.
Cvetković M., Reforma vizantijskog vojno-teritorijalnog uređenja u doba Justinijana II, Recueil des travaux de l'Institut d'études byzantines, 53, 2016, 17–46.
Debié M., Theophanes’ “Oriental Source”: What can we learn from Syriac Historiography?, M. Jankowiack, F. Montinaro, eds., Studies in Theophanes (= Travaux et Mémoires, 19), Paris, 2015, 365–382.
Dennis G., ed., The Taktika of Leo VI (= Dumbarton Oaks texts, 12), Washington, 2010.
Dvornik F., La Vie de Saint Grégoire le Décapolite, Slaves Macédoniens au IXe siècle, Paris, 1926.
Fine J. V. A., When ethnicity did not matter in the Balkans: a study of identity in pre-nationalist Croatia, Dalmatia, and Slavonia in the medieval and early-modern periods, Michigan, 2006.
Fine J., The Early medieval Balkans. A critical survey from the Sixth to the Late Twelfth Century, Michigan, 2008.
Gkoutzioukostas A., The term “Sklayēnia” and the Use of Adjectives which Derive from Ethnic Names in the History of Theophylact Simocatta, Cyril and Methodius: Byzantium and the World of the Slavs, International Scientific Conference, Thessalonica, 2015, 638–646.
Gkoutzioukostas A., “Sklavenia” revisited: previous and recent considerations, Parekbolai, An electronic journal for Byzantine literature, 7, 2017, 1–12.
Gregoire H., Les sources épigraphiques de l'histoire bulgare, Byzantion, 9, 1934, 745–786.
Gregoire H., Un Nouveau fragment du “Scriptor incertus de Leone Armenio”, Byzantion, 11, 1963, 417–427.
Haldon J. F., Byzantium in the Seventh Century, The Transformation of Culture, Cambridge, 1997.
Hupchick D., The Bulgarian Byzantine Wars for Early Medieval Balkan Hegemony, Wilkes-Barre, 2017.
Ivanov S. A., Feofilakt Simokata, G. G. Litavrin, ed., Corpus testimoniorum vetustissimorum ad historiam slavicam pertinentium, 2: VII–IX saecula, Moscow, 1995, 10–64.
Ivanova O. V., Formy politicheskoi organizatsii slavianskogo obshchestva v tsentral′noi i iuzhnoi chastiakh balkanskogo poluostrova v VII–VIII vv., G. G. Litavrin, ed., Etnosotsial′naia i politicheskaia struktura rannefeodal′nykh slavianskikh gosudarstv i narodnostei, Moscow, 1987, 56–65.
Ivanova O. V., Rasprostranenie khristianstva u slavian v Vizantii (VII–X vv.), G. G. Litavrin, ed., Priniatie khristianstva narodami Tsentral′noi i Iugo-Vostochnoi Evropy i kreshchenie Rusi, Moscow, 1988, 9–29.
Kehr P., ed., Epistolae Karolini Aevi, 5 (= Monumenta Germaniae Historica, Epistolarum, 7), Berlin, 1928.
Kehr P., ed., Ludowici Germanici, Karlomanni, Ludowici Ivnioris Diplomata (= Monumenta Germanica Historiae, Diplomata (DD), Diplomata regum Germaniae ex stirpe Karolinorum, 1), Berlin, 1934.
Kobylinski Z., The Slavs, P. Fouracre ed., The New Cambridge Medieval History, 1: c. 500– c. 700, Cambridge, 2008, 524–543.
Koder J., Vizantijski svet. Uvod u istorijsku geografiju istočnog Mediterana tokom vizantijslu epohe, V. Stanković, R. Radić, pr., Beograd, 2011.
Koder J., Sklavinien, Lexikon des Mittelalters, 7, München, 1995, 1988.
Kompa A., Gnesioi filoi: the Search for George Syncellus’ and Theophanes the Confessor’s Own Words, and the Authorship of Their Oeuvre, Studia Ceranea, 5, 2015, 155–230.
Lemerle P., ed. and tr., Les plus anciens Recueils des miracles de saint Demetrius, 1: Le texte, Paris, 1979.
Litavrin G. G., Ivanova O. V., Slaviane i Vizantiia, G. G. Litavrin, ed., Rannefeodal′nye gosudarstva na Balkanakh, VI–XII vv., Moscow, 1985, 34–98.
Litavrin G. G., Patriarkh Nikifor, G. G. Litavrin, ed., Corpus testimoniorum vetustissimorum ad historiam slavicam pertinentium, 2: VII–IX saecula, Moscow, 1995, 221–247.
Litavrin G. G., Slavinii VII–IX vv. Sotsial′no-politicheskie organizatsii slavian, L. A. Gindin et al., eds., Etnogenez narodov Balkan i Severnogo Prichernomor′ia, Moscow, 1984, 193–203.
Litavrin G., Sklaviniite od VII–IX v. kako socijalno-politička organizacija na Slovenite, Istorija, 21/2, Skopje, 1985, 21–29.
Louth A., Byzantium transforming (600–700), J. Shepard, ed., The Cambridge History of The Byzantine Empire, Cambridge, 2008, 221–249.
Louth A., Justinian and his legacy (500–600), J. Shepard ed., The Cambridge History of The Byzantine Empire, Cambridge, 2008, 99–129.
Lunt H. G., What the Rus' Primary Chronicle tells us about the origin of the Slavs and of Slavic Writing, Harvard Ukrainian Studies, 19 (= Kamen′ Kraeug″l′n″: Rhetoric Of The Medieval Slavic World), 1995, 335–357.
Malinovská N., The Development of the Concept of Sclavinia in the 12th Century and its Reflexion in the Polish Chronicle of Gallus Anonymus, Nové historické rozh′ady, 5/1, 43‒ 53.
Mango C., On re-reading the life of St. Gregory the Decapolite, Byzantina, 13/1, 1985, 635–646.
Mango C., Scott R., eds. and tr., The Chronicle of Theophanes Confessor, Byzantine and Near Eastern History, AD 284 – 813, Oxford, 1997.
Mango C., The Two Lives of St. Ioannikios and the Bulgarians, Harvard Ukrainian Studies, 7, 1983, 393–404.
Mango C., ed., Nicephori Patriarchae Constantinopolitani, Breviarium Historicum, (= Corpus Fontium Historiae Byzantiniae, 13), Washington, 1990.
Moffatt A., transl. and ed., Konstantinos Porphyrogennetos, The Book of ceremonies, (= Byzantina Australiensia, 18/2), Canberra, 2012.
Moravcsik G., Byzantinoturcica, 1, Leiden, 1983.
Naumenko V. Е., K voprosu o statuse slavianskikh «arkhontii» Makedonii i Gretsii v «temnye veka», Rossiia i mir: panorama istoricheskogo razvitiia: sbornik nauchnykh statei, posviashchennyi 70-letiiu istoricheskogo fakul′teta Ural′skogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im. A. M. Gor′kogo, Yekaterinburg, 2008, 179–189.
Neville L., Guide to Byzantine historical writing, Cambridge, 2018.
Obolensky D., Byzantium and the Slavs, New York, 1994.
Olajos T., Remarques sur la tradition manuscrite de l’Histoire Universelle de Théophylacte Simocatta, Revue d’Histoire des Textes, 9, 1979, 261–266.
Ostrogorsky G., Byzantium and the South Slavs, The Slavonic and East European Review, 42 (98), Dec., 1963, 1–14.
Ostrogorsky G., The Byzantine Empire in the World of the Seventh Century, Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 13, 1959, 1–21.
Pop-Atanasov G., Staroslovenski kirilometodievski izvori, Skopje, 2011.
Rajković M., obr., Teofan, G. Ostrogorski, ur., Fontes Byzantini Historiam Popularum Jugoslaviae Spectantes, 1, Beograd, 1955, 217–238.
Rajković M., Tomić M., obr., Patrijarh Nićifor, G. Ostrogorski, ur., Fontes Byzantini Historiam Popularum Jugoslaviae Spectantes, 1, Beograd, 1955, 239–244.
Serikov N. I., Ioann Efesskii, L. A. Gindin, G. G. Litavrin, ed., Corpus testimoniorum vetustissimorum ad historiam slavicam pertinentium, 1: I–VI saecula, Moscow, 1994, 276–291.
Setton K. M., The Bulgars in the Balkans and the Occupation of Corinth in the Seventh Century, Speculum, 25/4, Oct., 1950, 502–543.
Shchaveleva N. I., Drevniaia Rus′ v «Pol′skoi istorii» Iana Dlugosha (Knigi 1–6). Text, translation, commentary, Moscow, 2004.
Stephenson P., About the Emperor Nikephoros and How He Leaves His Bones in Bulgaria: A Context for the Controversial “Chronicle of 811”, Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 60, 2006, 87–109.
Stojkov S., «Sklavinija» kaj Teofilakt Simokata, Istorija, 53/1, Skopje, 2018, 15–40.
Treadgold W., The Byzantine revival (780 – 842), Stanford, 1988.
Treadgold W., The Middle Byzantine Historians, Basingstoke, 2013.
Treadgold W., Trajan the Patrician, Nicephorus, and Theophanes, D. Bumazhnov, E. Grypeou, T. B. Sailors, A. Toepel eds, Bibel, Byzanz Und Christlicher Orient, Festschrift für Stephen Gerö zum 65. Geburtstag (= Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta, 187), Leuven, Paris, Walpole, 2011, 590–621.
Turtledove H., The Chronicle of Theophanes, Philadelphia, 1982.
Vedriš T., Balkanske sklavinije i Bugarska, N. Z. Jakus, Povijest Hrvata, 1: Nova zraka u europskom svjetlu. Hrvatske zemlje u ranome srednjem vijeku (oko 550 – oko 1150), Zagreb, 2015, 581–608.
Vlasto A. P., The Entry of The Slavs into Christendom, An introduction to The Medieval History of The Slavs, New York, 1970.
Whittow M., The Making of Byzantium, 600–1025, London, Basingstock, 1996.
Živković T., The Urban Landcape of Early Medieval Slavic Principalities in the Territories of the Former Praefectura Illyricum and in the Province of Dalmatia (ca. 610–950), S. Rudić, ed., The World of the Slavs, Studies on the East, West and South Slavs: Civitas, Oppidas, Villas and Archeological Evidence (7th to 11th Centuries AD), Belgrade, 2013, 15–38.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Copyright (c) 2020 Stoyko Stoykov
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.